47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
SEE ALL PHOTOS
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
47 Tonetta Lake Way
Courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty, Hope Ross Mazzola Listing Contact: 914-232-7000 
For Sale

47 Tonetta Lake Way

47 Tonetta Lake Way, Brewster, NY 10509

$515,000
Full of warmth and character, this 2-bedroom, 1-bath home shines with beautiful wood floors, an updated kitchen and bath, and a spacious family room designed for everyday comfort and easy gatherings. A bonus walk-up attic offers exciting potential--perfect for a future playroom, home office, or cozy loft retreat.

Behind the scenes, the home has been thoughtfully maintained with key updates including an above-ground oil tank, 2023 hot water heater, Weil-McLain oil burner, generator transfer switch, water softener system, and a 14-year-young roof--giving you peace of mind from day one.

Step outside and discover your own private escape. A beautifully crafted stone patio with gazebo sets the stage for summer evenings, while stone steps lead to an upper level and a generous side yard ideal for play, gardening, or simply relaxing. Two sheds provide plenty of extra storage.

The lifestyle here is the real standout. With optional membership (just $150/year), Lake Tonetta offers a sandy beach, swimming, boating, fishing, and a vibrant neighborhood atmosphere with community events throughout the year. Spend your summers by the water, your fall evenings gathered outdoors, and your winters curled up by the fire.

Charming, well cared for, and perfectly positioned to enjoy the best of lake living--this is the kind of home that just feels right.

4/26/2026 12:00PM - 3:00PM EDT

2
beds

1
bath

1,162 Sq.Ft. LIVING AREA

8,625 Sq.Ft. lot

Hope Mazzola

Hope Mazzola

Features & Amenities

Interior

  • total bedrooms2
  • Total bathroom1
  • full bathroom1
  • Laundry room In Basement
  • Flooring Wood
  • APPLIANCES Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Oven, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Washer, Water Softener Owned
  • other interior Features Cathedral Ceiling(s), Eat-in Kitchen, Original Details

Area & Lot

  • Status For Sale
  • OPEN HOUSE

    4/26/2026 12:00PM - 3:00PM EDT

  • Living Area1,162 Sq.Ft.
  • Total Area1,550 Sq.Ft.
  • Lot Area8,625 Sq.Ft.
  • MLS® ID963467
  • TypeResidential
  • YEAR BUILT1950
  • Architecture StylesCottage
  • Elementary SchoolJohn F. Kennedy
  • Middle SchoolHenry H Wells Middle School
  • High SchoolBrewster High School
  • School DistrictBrewster

Exterior

  • water SourceWell
  • utilitiesElectricity Connected
  • parkingDriveway
  • HEAT TYPEBaseboard
  • AIR CONDITIONINGWall/Window Unit(s)
  • sewerSeptic Tank
  • HOA AmenitiesBoat Dock, Other, Playground

Financial

  • Sales Price$515,000
  • Real Estate Tax $6,213/yr
  • HOA $150/yr

Mortgage Calculator

Estimate your monthly mortgage payment, including the principal and interest, property taxes, and HOA. Adjust the values to generate a more accurate rate.

All estimates are provided for informational purposes only. Actual amounts may vary.
$0,000 Your Payment 20 15 65
$0,000 Your Payment
image

Schedule a Showing

We would love to show you our beautiful property. Please select your preferred date and time below. An agent will be in touch shortly to confirm your appointment.

Schedule a Showing

We would love to show you our beautiful property. Please select your preferred date and time below. An agent will be in touch shortly to confirm your appointment.

Thank you for your interest in 47 Tonetta Lake Way, Brewster, NY 10509. We are reviewing your request and will be in touch shortly!

Work With

Hope has dedicated the last 22 years to honing her craft and knowing the current state of the real estate industry inside and out. There is a reason why Hope has stacked up accolades year after year but what does that mean for YOU? Hope is connected, respected, and working harder now than ever before to ensure a successful and amazing real estate experience. Here is the best advice:

Follow Hope on Instagram